The Short Answer
- Photos and complex images → WebP (lossy, 25-35% smaller than JPEG at equal quality)
- Logos, icons, UI elements, screenshots → PNG (lossless, pixel-perfect edges)
- Transparency needed with photos → WebP (lossless or lossy with alpha channel)
- Maximum compression, accept encoding time → AVIF (20-30% smaller than WebP, slower to encode)
WebP: Now the Default for Web Photos
WebP reached 97%+ browser support by 2022 and has been the practical default for web image delivery since 2023. It offers lossy mode 25-35% smaller than JPEG, lossless mode 20-30% smaller than PNG, and alpha channel support in both modes.PNG: Still Non-Negotiable for Specific Cases
PNG's lossless guarantee makes it the only correct choice for:- Screenshots and UI mockups: Interfaces have hard edges between buttons, text, and backgrounds. Any lossy compression introduces visible ringing at these edges.
- Line art and technical diagrams: Crisp lines at pixel-perfect positions.
- Source files for editing: If you will open, edit, and re-save an image repeatedly, only lossless formats avoid progressive quality degradation.
AVIF: Use It Where You Can
AVIF (AV1 Image File Format) is technically superior to WebP — 20-30% smaller at equivalent quality, with HDR and wide color gamut support. The catch: encoding is very slow (5-30 seconds per image). Browser support in 2026 is approximately 88-90% globally.For maximum compatibility, use:
``html

``
This serves AVIF to supporting browsers, WebP as the wide-support middle layer, and JPEG as the universal fallback.